A Laboratory Under Siege: The Fate of California’s Clean Air Act Waiver

By: Annmarie Buckley

As the Trump Administration and several states grapple with the application of a key vehicle emissions regulation provision, the United States is on the precipice of a major shift in environmental law and policy. The impending shift implicates an uncertain future for state air quality regulatory regimes and the entire automobile industry.

In June of 2025, California, alongside eleven other states, sued the federal government, President Trump, and the United States Environmental Protection Agency (“EPA”) for improperly blocking its implementation of stringent emissions standards under what is known as a “California waiver” of the Clean Air Act (“CAA”).[1] When Congress passed the CAA in 1967, it included a “waiver” provision, allowing California to set its own emissions standards that would not be preempted by the federal government’s standards, so long as they were consistent with the CAA and were appropriate to address California’s particular public health and welfare concerns about air pollution.

California has long been a leading force in air pollution control, and California and states that opt in to its standards claim that federal override of its aggressive emissions standards runs afoul of federalist values. No matter how the situation resolves, the pending lawsuit will have resounding economic, environmental, and public health impacts.

The Clean Air Act and the California Waiver

When the CAA was first enacted in 1967, Congress preempted state governments from setting their own emissions standards.[2] Prior to the CAA, however, California had already established air pollution regulations. State legislation enacted in 1959 required the California State Department of Public Health to establish air quality standards, including necessary controls for motor vehicle emissions.[3]

Recognizing that California struggled acutely with high levels of air pollution, Congress granted it authority to set its own standards.[4] This independence allowed California to become “a unique laboratory . . . to develop effective control devices which can become a part of the resources of this nation.”[5] Thus, the California waiver is a prime example of a key strength of federalism: allowing states to try new regulatory regimes can encourage policy innovation that benefits the country as a whole. Furthermore, Congress allowed states to opt-in to California’s emissions standards, so California’s more stringent policy could replace federal policy elsewhere.[6]

For California’s emissions standards to be enforceable, it must request a waiver or authorization from federal preemption of state regulations.[7] Under the CAA, the EPA should grant that waiver unless the EPA Administrator finds that California “was arbitrary and capricious in its finding that its standards are, in the aggregate, at least as protective of public health and welfare as applicable federal standards; does not need such standards to meet compelling and extraordinary conditions; or such standards and accompanying enforcement procedures are not consistent with Section 202(a) of the Clean Air Act.” In other words, the Administrator should generally grant the waiver unless California’s proposed emissions standards are wildly out of line with the CAA.

Most Recent California Emissions Standards

Between December 2024 and April 2025, the EPA granted waivers for the most recent wave of California emissions regulations.[9] The key regulations were the Advanced Clean Cars II (“ACC II”), Heavy-Duty Omnibus Low NOx, and the Advanced Clean Trucks regulation.[10] These regulations, among other things, have the goal of decreasing emissions by mandating increasing percentages of zero emissions vehicles (“ZEVs”) and plug-in hybrid electric vehicles (“PHEVs”) to be sold in California.[11] The regulations also significantly tighten emissions standards for non-ZEV and non-PHEV vehicles.[12]

Intervention Under the Congressional Review Act

            Joint resolutions of disapproval for the above regulations have been introduced in Congress.[13] The authority for those resolutions is claimed under the Congressional Review Act (“CRA”).[14] The CRA allows Congress to review rules promulgated by federal agencies.[15] Importantly, the CRA only applies to “rules,” not “orders.”[16] Orders are a product of agency adjudications and usually apply to particular parties rather than operating as generally applicable regulations.[17] Back in March 2022, the Government Accountability Office (“GAO”), the agency Congress relies upon for questions surrounding the CRA, determined that California’s waivers for emissions regulations were considered orders rather than rules.[18] This was because they applied directly to California after quasi-adjudicatory review by the agency, with conclusions drawn from the agency’s fact-finding and discretion.[19] The then GAO reaffirmed this opinion after an inquiry from several Senators in February 2025.[20] Notwithstanding this nonbinding GAO opinion, the House of Representatives passed three joint resolutions to block the waivers in April and May of 2025.[21]

Now, California and several other states that have adopted California’s emissions standards are suing, stating the CRA was improperly used to block these regulations. In its complaint, California claims that the “[t]he Federal Government ran roughshod over federalism and separation of powers principles in applying the CRA to . . . preemption waiver decisions,” despite the long-standing notion that waivers were not rules to which the CRA applied.[22] The complaint also emphasizes how the CRA has never been used to invalidate CAA waivers, and accuses President Trump and members of Congress of using the CRA as a “quick and easy way to ‘take . . . down’ California’s regulations.”[23] The complaint calls for the Court to “declare that the [resolutions invalidating California’s regulations] have no effect on the status or enforceability of state emissions control programs,” and to “require the EPA to implement the Clean Air Act . . . in a manner consistent with the three waivers as granted.”[24]

Ongoing Litigation and its Potential Consequences

            There are three bills currently pending in Congress that attempt to curb California’s ability to adopt emissions standards independent of the federal government.[25] As noted by Dan Quinley and Kerry Shea of Davis Wright Tremaine, LLC, it is unlikely that Congress will be able to pass this legislation.[26] So, the answer to the CRA’s applicability will likely be tied up in the courts for quite a long time. Until then, the ongoing uncertainty about the future of California waivers adds to the overall uncertainty permeating through the environmental law landscape.

_______________________________________________

[1]Carly Nairn, California fights for its right to strict emission waivers, Courthouse News Service (Feb. 19, 2026), https://www.courthousenews.com/california-fights-for-its-right-to-strict-emission-waivers/ [https://perma.cc/SJ8N-645U].

[2]Benjamin M. Barczewski, Kathryn G. Kynett & Emily N. Peterson, California and the Clean Air Act (CAA) Waiver: Frequently Asked Questions, Cong. Rsch. Serv. Rep. No. R48168 (May 9, 2025), https://www.congress.gov/crs-product/R48168[https://perma.cc/2BEW-UR69].

[3]Id.

[4]Id.

[5]Id.

[6]Id.

[7]Id.

[8]U.S. Envtl. Prot. Agency, Vehicle Emissions California Waivers and Authorizations (last updated Feb. 10, 2026), https://www.epa.gov/state-and-local-transportation/vehicle-emissions-california-waivers-and-authorizations#ACCP[https://perma.cc/8U57-563L].

[9]Barczewski et al., California and the Clean Air Act (CAA) Waiver, supra note 2.

[10]Id.

[11]LegalClarity California, California Advanced Clean Cars II: Rules and Requirements (Dec. 12, 2025), https://legalclarity.org/california-advanced-clean-cars-ii-rules-and-requirements/[https://perma.cc/4ARE-NR2G].

[12]Id.

[13]Barczewski et al., California and the Clean Air Act (CAA) Waiver, supra note 2.

[14]Id.

[15]Id.

[16]Id.

[17]Id.

[18]Id.

[19]Id.

[20]Id.

[21]Id.

[22]Complaint at 4, State of California et al. v. United States of America, et al., No. 3:25-CV-04966 (N.D. Cal. June 12, 2025).

[23]Id.

[24]Id. at 5.

[25]Dan Quinley & Kerry E. Shea, California Attempts to Catch a “Waive”: State Leads 10 Others Suing Trump Administration Over Revocation of Vehicle Emission Waivers, Davis Wright Tremaine LLP (June 17, 2025), https://www.dwt.com/blogs/energy–environmental-law-blog/2025/06/california-epa-clean-air-emission-waivers-lawsuit[https://perma.cc/BSG9-3EGT].

[26]Id.